Like Roy Batty’s tears-in-the-rain monologue at the end of Blade Runner, I’ve seen terrible live-action anime movies you people wouldn’t believe. Scarlett Johansson’s Ghost in the Shell, whatever the hell they thought they were cooking with Dragon Ball Evolution, and I can’t even bring myself to hate-watch the live-action Avatar: The Last Airbender again. By that same token, I’ve also encountered some good ones: Ichi the Killer, Battle Angel Alita, and Tom Cruise and Emily Blunt’s Edge of Tomorrow, to name a few.
But of all the things I’ve watched, whenever someone asks me what the greatest live-action anime work is, my answer isn’t Netflix’s One Piece—despite its claim to fame as “the one that broke the curse.” It’s the Wachowskis’ Speed Racer: a live-action masterpiece that was ahead of its time, the kind of film I’ll drop everything to rewatch just to feel that magic again, as I did this past weekend. And I’m tired of anime fans pretending that it isn’t.
Off rip, a live-action anime anything comes with the misplaced, baked-in conceit that it has something more worthwhile to offer than its animated counterpart. It’s why the whole venture is tantamount to a fool’s errand, with varying degrees of cringe waiting in the wings to traumatize any fandom white-knuckling over how their darlings will be killed on opening night. Why? Because the magic of an animated work—the secret sauce that makes it sing—is that it’s animated.
If I had to quantify the pitfall every bad live-action adaptation tumbles into, it’s that it’s realized in a way that feels ashamed of its source material. That shame can manifest as a cheeky meta-joke about how silly its premise looks in the adaptation’s dark, gritty real world, à la the early Marvel/Fox movies. Either that, or (far more grating as of late) an adaptation becomes so doggedly obsessed with “being for the fans” that it gorges itself with mile-a-minute Easter eggs and references until all it can hope to be is a pretty, feature-length jingling of keys that rings—a commercial that rings hollow in the arena of storytelling.
Speed Racer is the antithesis of that very notion.
What’s so viscerally refreshing about Speed Racer, especially when stacked against the usual detritus of live-action anime, is that it doesn’t resign itself to how many nods it can cram into its runtime for a cheap pop from audiences in the know. It rejects the hollow, frictionless content disguised as films that have become so in vogue today. And it does so by the Wachowskis actually giving a damn, enriching the movie with real themes—y’know, the things movies have. Themes that’ve become signature in their work: art, the corporate bastardization of that art into content for a quick buck, and the struggle to preserve something meaningful in a system built to strip it for parts for infinite wealth.
In Speed Racer, cars are Speed’s art; the deadly races and money-hungry corporate sponsors circling them are what’s bastardizing his art—some going so far as to say the thing he fell in love with was fixed from the day he first fell in love with it. His refusal to sell out, his insistence on honoring his not-quite-dead brother Racer X’s legacy by preserving his record in the film’s climax, is the emotional engine that makes the film hum brilliantly all these years later. Though if I were to name-drop a moment that makes me go hell yeah every single time, it’s a scene where Speed lets his nuts hang (metaphorically, of course) by knocking a rival racer aside and spitting, “Get that weak shit off my track.” It rocks. Every time.
Sure, the film veers into complete nonsense whenever the boy and the monkey show up, and the copious green‑screen backdrops can make you a little nauseous as characters swipe across the frame in both races and dialogue scenes. But that very energy—the hyperstylized, panel-to-panel momentum—captures the feeling of reading a manga, the way your mind stitches together static images into motion.
That’s why Speed Racer leaves other live-action adaptations in its dust: it’s unafraid to be silly, unafraid to look weird, and unafraid to say something without collapsing into a commercial for its own IP. It’s one of the greatest live‑action anime films ever made precisely because it refuses to be ashamed of what it is.
Want more io9 news? Check out when to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s next for the DC Universe on film and TV, and everything you need to know about the future of Doctor Who.
Read the full article here
